Having completed Tiamat campaigns at 15th level, my paladin had some time to re-think his worldview. Now he wants to change from Oath of Vengeance to the homebrew Oath of the Common Man.
Paladin of Common Man roughly upholds the following tenets:
- Equality
- Community
- Respect
- Change
- Labor
He stands as protector of peasants and laborers against oppressing lords and other folks preying upon their hard toil. His powers are drawn upon respect for the value of common men and their labor, their shared burden and effort. He seeks justice for destitute masses guided by revolutionary spirit to change the world for the greater good of honestly working people.
I've presented my group the Common Man paladin's Oath several months ago (just for fun) and they seemed OK with it, GM included, so I think that there's not a problem with this oath, but it's not clear to me how to transition an existing character to it.
I am aware of rules for Oathbreakers but this is certainly not that case. My paladin isn't going to be some villain commanding undead hordes but a hero of masses of common labourers, neglected and abused by their lords and ravaged by war. Irreligious perhaps but not evil.
Are there any rules for renouncing an oath and replacing it with another one?
Best Answer
RAW:
The Player's Handbook states
And the DM's Guide states:
Although the rules do not specifically state that a paladin must follow a god, these passages as well as spell names imply that there is a divine connection.
RAF:
I would rule that you have broken one oath (OoV) in favor of another oath (OoCM). Thus, you are required to change deity to one that suits the new oath; God(dess) of the Hearth or God(dess) of the Harvest for example.
Due to this change of deity, and possibly alignment, you loose all abilities given by OoV, but keep fighting skills. In order to gain the abilities for the new oath, you must complete a quest given by the new deity (church) as an act of penance. The quest should be a challenge for your current paladin level.
I present the following caveats: