[RPG] Changing Type Of Enethe During Combat

combatdnd-4egm-techniquesminion

Hypothetic scenario: A ranger does a stealth check and succeeds. While moving he notices two patrols and decides to attack them using Two Fanged Strike. The patrols are normally minions. He gets to kill the first but the second one sees him, so now he has to fight him, but a minion would be really easy to kill.

The Question : Is it against the rules to change the type of the patrol from minion to soldier?

Best Answer

Minions Are People Too

The minion-ness of a monster in D&D 4E measures its effective threat versus the PCs. It is not usually some in-character property that the PCs or NPCs are aware of. It just so happens that the first sword, spell or whatever that connects shows its true deadly nature. The whole setup with minions is very much inline with cinematic storytelling, and very much the opposite of a simulation.

So, in terms of what the game stats are supposed to represent, anything that seriously increases the threat status of a minion logically in the game world is a good enough reason to change its type. That includes it going from unaware to aware of being attacked in an infiltrate-the-castle challenge.

However, you should take care

  • Try to be consistent and not arbitrary. If the guards are minions when being stalked through stealth, but become a tougher fight when prepared, this should apply to that type of creature in similar situations, otherwise the players will not understand how to play the game you are creating.

  • There is no need to make every conflict in the game a serious challenge. Resolving meaningful combat challenges in 4E can take a lot of time.

An easier solution

Any minion not killed in the first attack calls up the two nearest patrols and now the Ranger has to fight 5 minions. Similar risk level, and added bonus the Ranger feels more like a hero when he beats them all.

Related Topic