[RPG] choose which damage type the Sneak Attack does if the weapon does multiple types

damagedamage-typesdnd-5eroguesneak-attack

Sneak Attack has the same type as the rest of the attack, this is easy, unless there are multiple damage types.

A Flame Tongue does slashing (or piercing) damage, and fire. Can I chose the Sneak Attack damage in this case to be fire too?

Best Answer

Maybe

First, Crawford did tweet under Sage Advice that

All Damage has a Type

This then leads us to the question of what damage type Sneak Attack should use.

In support of Primary type of damage

As you linked, Sneak Attack delivers damage of the primary type of the weapon (piercing, slashing, etc.)

The Flame Tongue states that it, (DMG, 170):

...deals an extra 2d6 fire damage...

emphasis mine

Jeremy Crawford also supports this with his Sage Advice answer:

QUESTION: Sneak attack has the same damage type of the weapon used?

ANSWER: That's correct

Therefore, the sneak attack damage of the Flame Tongue is that of the primary type of your flame tongue (whatever it may be) and NOT the fire damage.

In support of Choosing your damage type

Crawford suggests you may have a choice, though, in cases of multiple damage types

In another question about Hunters Mark Damage, Crawford answers somewhat differently:

Hunter's mark uses the same damage type as the attack that triggers it. If the attack has more than one damage type, choose one.

I don't think those two responses are at odds. You must use the damage type of the weapon, but if the weapon/strike delivers multiple damage types then you may pick. The Flame Tongue would give you that option for fire damage on Sneak Attack if you extrapolate this ruling on Hunters Mark to Sneak Attack.