[RPG] Do the attunement requirements of the Hammer of Thunderbolts make it situational

attunementdnd-5emagic-itemsweapons

The properties of the hammer of thunderbolts seem to suggest to me that (for the vast majority of the time) the player owning this item will not have it attuned. How do you rule on the current attunement status of this item at any given moment, given that players will almost certainly not "live" in their gauntlets of ogre power?

The description of the hammer of thunderbolts says (emphasis mine):

You must be wearing a belt of giant strength (any variety) and
gauntlets of ogre power to attune to this weapon. The attunement ends
if you take off either of those items.

I can certainly see very specific cases say for example when the owner takes a specific short rest prior to entering the tower to specifically re-attune the weapon, but what about for encounters where there is less opportunity to plan. What about encounters that happen several hours after a short rest where the player might reasonably have been expected to take their gauntlets off to eat, drink, shake hands, wipe their brow, read a map, go to the bathroom…

I'm not asking about whether the gauntlets must be attuned to, as I believe that question has been settled and only wearing them is required. See this unofficial tweet by rules designer Jeremy Crawford from January 2018:

Hammer of thunderbolts has a special property that requires you to be
wearing two other specific magic items. The text of hammer of
thunderbolts doesn't say you must be attuned to them.

However, as quoted above, the description of the hammer of thunderbolts says one's attunement to it ends if you "take off" either of the two other magic items.

How should I rule on the current attunement status of this item at any given moment (e.g. in the event of a random encounter or after a reasonable amount of time has passed since it was last attuned), given that players will almost certainly not "live" in their gauntlets of ogre power?

Best Answer

It's going to be up to the DM, but there isn't a specific rule requiring removal of gauntlets or belts.

Neither the gauntlets nor the belt count as 'armor' in terms of donning/doffing or even limiting attunement by class or race. Because of that, there is no written rule about whether a character must take them off to do anything.

It is entirely up to the purview of the DM, along with how a player wants to play their character, to determine if this is actually an issue.

I would generally recommend not having it be an issue, though. If the table has come up with a path to get these items, don't take it away - or if you do, give them the time necessary to reattune.