Drow vs. Elves in a dungeon with no natural light. Torch light for elven party. If a drow drops a darkness spell on an object in the middle of the party are they effectively blind? If they had a dancing lights spell in the party does the darkness dispel the dancing lights, or just nullify it until you move it out of the darkness?
[RPG] Does Darkness dispel Dancing Lights
dnd-3.5espells
Best Answer
Darkness
Dancing lights
Since dancing lights is a light spell of a lower level than darkness, it does not light any area within the darkness. Higher-level light spells, like daylight, would overcome darkness and light the area in spite of darkness.
It is unclear whether or not the dancing lights are, themselves, visible as points of light. Darkness prevents them from lighting any area, but they could be visible themselves without illuminating any surrounding area. Up to you, as DM, to decide that. If the lights themselves are visible, they could be used for signaling and silent communication within the darkness.
Carrying, Movement, and Exploration > Vision and Light
So yes, the party is blind. Note that this includes those who do have darkvision, despite the bolded statement above, because darkness includes the following special case:
So not only are the humans, elves, gnomes, and so on blind, but so are the dwarf and half-orc. But perhaps most importantly, so are the drow. Thus, for the drow, darkness is much more effective for misdirection, retreat, or divide and conquer strategies.
The ability to see in magical darkness is generally reserved for devils; even magic that grants this ability is often named after devils, such as the devil’s sight invocation in Complete Arcane.