[RPG] Does either end of a Rope of Climbing fasten on command

dnd-5emagic-items

Can either end of a Rope of Climbing be commanded to attach – or just the end opposite to what you are holding?

If you hold one end of the rope and use an action to speak the Command
Word, the rope animates. As a Bonus Action, you can Command the other
end to move toward a destination you choose…You can also tell the
rope to fasten itself securely to an object or to unfasten itself, to
knot or unknot itself, or to coil itself for carrying.

After animated – can you let go of the rope after it is animated or do you have to hold it the whole time? Even if you have to hold it to command it – could you command either end to fasten to something? (Thus ensuring a “magically” secure attachment at both ends.)

——

Addendum: After reading the answers below – it raises the question whether a PC can grab one end of the rope – tell it to fasten to them – then grab that fastened end and tell the other end to go fasten elsewhere – thus giving a “secure” attachment at both ends. This would likely depend upon whether a DM rules you can “hold” the end of a fastened rope.

Best Answer

Can either end of a Rope of Climbing be commanded to attach - or just the end opposite to what you are holding?

It seems to me that the rules you quoted are pretty clear that only the other end can move or fasten. Emphasis added:

If you hold one end of the rope and use an action to speak the Command Word, the rope animates. As a Bonus Action, you can Command the other end to move toward a destination you choose...You can also tell the rope to fasten itself securely to an object or to unfasten itself, to knot or unknot itself, or to coil itself for carrying.

Your other questions:

After animated - can you let go of the rope after it is animated or do you have to hold it the whole time?

This is a little murkier, but I think as written, commanding the rope requires you to hold one end and use the command word. If you let go, you no longer meet the initial conditions for giving commands.

Even if you have to hold it to command it - could you command either end to fasten to something? (Thus ensuring a “magically” secure attachment at both ends.)

Nowhere in the rules for this item does it say that the knot is 'magical'. The rope is magical in that it can move and knot itself, but as written, anyone would be able to untie that knot.

Related Topic