[RPG] Holding a longbow (or other 2H weapon) and attacking with a shortsword (or other 1H weapon)

combatdnd-5eweapons

I have a question about how the rules handle holding a two-handed weapon and then drawing and attacking with a one-handed weapon. You are able to drop a weapon (or in the case of a two-handed weapon, let go of it with one of your hands) without expending your free object interaction (according to this clarification). According to the PHB, you can then use your free object interaction to draw a weapon, let's say a Shortsword in this case.

PHB Page 190. You can also interact with one object or feature of the
environment for free, during either your move or your
action. For example, you could open a door during your
move as you stride toward a foe, or you could draw your
weapon as part of the same action you use to attack.

The PHB Errata also says that two-handed weapons require two hands to use, but not to simply hold.

PHB Errata. Two-Handed (p. 147).
This property
is relevant only when you attack with the
weapon, not when you simply hold it.

So, my question is, can I perform this sequence of events during my turn?

  1. Let go of my longbow with one hand without consuming a free object interaction or action, leaving it to be held in one hand.
  2. With my free hand, draw a shortsword as a free object interaction.
  3. Use my action to attack with the shortsword.

And if so, in the following round, can I do the following?

  1. Sheathe the shortsword as part of my free object interaction.
  2. Use my action to Attack with the bow, now having my other hand free to "use" the weapon as specified by the two-handed property.

This comes up as a result of this question's answer. It seems to be that you can let go of your bow to do something such as cast a spell with somatic gestures using the now-free hand, so I was naturally wondering if you could do other such things with your free hand.

Best Answer

On recommendation I'll post what I believe to be the correct answer in relation to the rules.

Both Sequences of Rounds Are Legal

Jeremy Crawford's tweet in relation to object interactions classifies dropping a weapon as free and "not requiring extensive effort" in contrast to picking up a weapon, explicitly stated to be an object interaction. Therefore, we can assume that dropping or letting go of your weapon (be it with one hand or two hands) does not consume your free object interaction on your turn. So one can simply let go of the bow with one hand and leave it to be held in the other.

The PHB Errata clarifies that is perfectly legal for a character to hold their 2H weapon with one hand, ostensibly leaving the other hand free for whatever interaction one wishes.

PHB Errata. Two-Handed (p. 147). This property is relevant only when you attack with the weapon, not when you simply hold it.

Then, according to the PHB, we can use our free object interaction to draw a one-handed weapon (or perform other actions/gestures requiring the use of a free hand, such as casting) with our free hand.

PHB, Page 190. ...or you could draw your weapon as part of the same action you use to attack.

Seeing as everything done up to this point requires no action, the sequence of events in the question are perfectly legal. A character wielding a longbow would be able to hold their bow with one hand and attack with a Shortsword (or similar, or cast) with the other after drawing the appropriate weapon in the same turn.

As for the second round of events, sheathing the 1H weapon would also qualify as our one free object interaction for the round. There is also no indication in the rules that you must use any sort of object interaction to allow the use of your longbow for an attack as long as it is equipped. The two-handed property only specifies that the weapon requires two hands to use, and we have functional use of both. Any interaction with the weapon with both of our hands would fall under the domain of our attack action.

Related Topic