[RPG] How flexible is the size of Mold Earth

area-of-effectcantripsdnd-5espells

The transmutation cantrip mold earth (EEPC, p. 21; XGtE, p. 162-163) explicitly states:

You choose a portion of dirt or stone […] that fits within a 5-foot cube.

Would this indicate that the total amount of dirt or stone you can manipulate has to be to able to fit in a 5 foot cube, not necessarily that it does?

For example, one of the effects this spell can do is turn dirt/stone into difficult terrain. With this spell, could a caster turn 60 5ft. squares into difficult terrain, if they're an inch thick?
If I did my maths right that total ammount of dirt could fit in a 5 foot cube.

Is this how one should read this spell? Or, does it mean you can only turn 5ft. of dirt/stone into difficult terrain, making it the equivalent of a muddy puddle one can pretty easily side step with little to no consequences?

Best Answer

There is no flexibility in the casting of this spell

As you stated, Mold Earth says:

You choose a portion of dirt or stone that you can see within range and that fits within a 5-foot cube.

While your maths is right, 60 one foot thick slices of soil/dirt could fit into a 5 ft cube, this spell requires a target area that already 'fits within a 5-foot cube' not that 'could fit within a 5-foot cube'.

Is there another way to exploit this cantrip to effect a larger area?

Not really, certainly not to achieve anything like the area of effect you were hoping for (60 ft.). You could effect a maximum of two 5 ft. cubes at once (10 ft.), rather than one.

The spell states:

This change lasts for 1 hour.

Assuming one action every six seconds, you could cast Mold Earth 600 times in an hour. This sounds like a fun way to pass the time in principle, when you're waiting to lay an ambush, however, abusing the cantrip in this way has been clearly ruled out:

If you cast this spell multiple times, you can have no more than two of its non-instantaneous effects active at a time.