[RPG] How much damage can a druid Wild Shaped into a spider take without dying instantly

dnd-5ewild-shape

A human druid Wild Shapes into a spider and now has 1 maximum hit point. As a spider she gets bitten by a hungry lizard that deals 2 damage.

Does the druid die from Instant Death (PHB p. 197), or does she revert to her human form first (PHB pp. 66–7)?

Best Answer

The relevant rules are Wild Shape on pages 66 - 67:

You automatically revert if you fall unconscious, drop to 0 hit points, or die.

...

If you revert as a result of dropping to 0 hit points, any excess damage carries over to your normal form. For example, if you take 10 damage in animal form and have only 1 hit point left, you revert and take 9 damage. As long as the excess damage doesn't reduce your normal form to 0 hit points, you aren't knocked unconscious.

The other relevant bits are on 197:

When damage reduces you to 0 hit points, and there is damage remaining, you die if the remaining damage equals or exceeds your hit point maximum.

...

If she takes 18 damage from an attack, she is reduced to 0 hit points, but 12 damage remains. Because the remaining damage equals her hit point maximum, the cleric dies.

There are two ways to interpret the instant death rules:

  • Instant death is fundamentally, a single, atomic, operation. You apply the damage, and then under certain circumstances the target dies. Any sequencing in the description is purely to help understand the process.

  • Instant death is a series of steps. "Remains" implies a two phase process: apply the damage, and then check what's left. Nothing "remains" unless it is "remaining after" something else. The example is also done in very distinct steps: The cleric takes damage, is reduced to 0 hit points, then the remaining damage is checked, then the cleric dies.

If you subscribe to the first interpretation, then a spider-druid dies when they take 2 points of damage. They take the damage, it is instantly fatal, and they revert form. There is an explicit special case to prevent unconsciousness, but there isn't one to prevent death. The druid is dead.

If you subscribe to the second, then the spider-druid can take a normal amount of damage before dying. He reaches zero, reverts to druid, instant death is checked against his druid hit points, and the special-case against unconsciousness kicks in to keep him on his feet.

There is ultimately no way to resolve the atomicity of the instant death process, short of "Word of God" from a developer.

For my table, I like Druids to use their abilities as something other than a combat cooldown. But if turning into a sparrow to serenade the innkeeper's daughter means you instantly die when you fail the perception check to spot her cat Boots... Well, you aren't going to have many druids turning into things other than tigers or bears.

Therefore, I must rule for interpretation two. Because it's the only one that supports my playstyle. Your table may vary.

One final bit of food for thought:

The 4th-level spell Polymorph uses the same mechanics as the Druid's wildshape ability. So if you rule that instant-death is very fatal for shapeshifters, hope your players never realize that they can just start turning the bad guys into box turtles and stepping on them.