[RPG] How resilient is the Staff of the Magi

dnd-5emagic-items

I have a sorcerer in a D&D campaign that for some reason found a Deck of Many Things, from which he acquired a Staff of the Magi.

According to the item entry, it says that:

This staff can be wielded as a magic quarterstaff

But it also has the Retributive Strike ability:

You can use an action to break the staff over your knee or against a solid surface, performing a retributive strike.

I'm scared of actually breaking the thing if I were to use it as a melee weapon in a desperate situation. Would the staff be safe to hit things because it can be used as a "magic quarterstaff"? Or would it break on impact and explode as a retributive strike? Or would it be something that is most likely up to the DM so I may as well not even tempt luck?

Best Answer

There is no chance to break it in an attack

The description of the staff does not mention that it is especially susceptible to damage, and the general rule is:

Thanks to a combination of careful crafting and magical reinforcement, a magic item is at least as durable as a nonmagical item of its kind. (DMG 141)

Using the retributive strike feature of the item is a separate action that you have to decide to take. It is not a part or feature of a normal melee attack.

You can use an action to break the staff over your knee or against a solid surface (DMG 203)

Also, a creature rarely constitutes a solid surface and whacking walls with the intent to damage them is just an inherently useless thing to do.