I'm starting a new campaign and for the first time ever and I'm trying a Psychic spell caster (Psychic, specifically.)
My GM is pretty adamant that the metamagic Still Spell and Silent Spell exist for a reason, and that Thought/Emotion components are clearly detectable in the same way – and what's more, that with Deceitful & Cunning Caster, I take the same -4 penalty to Bluff attempts for Thought/Emotion.
Is psychic casting (with Thought/Emotion components) detectable in the same way as Somatic/Verbal components?
I follow his concerns about balance, and he's got thousands of hours more under his belt in PF than I do, but I feel like this is the point with Psychic casting. It's baked into the classes for a reason, and RAW/RAI is being ignored because he's worried about balance.
Am I in the wrong, or am I misunderstanding anything about Psychic casting?
Best Answer
You are correct about the components of psychic spellcasting. The GM should have looked at the rules on psychic spellcasting before allowing one of their players to be an occult caster. The rules are pretty explicit about the following:
But don't be fooled! Occult casters still need to concentrate like traditional casters, and psychic spellcasting can still provoke attacks of opportunity. There are even new Metamagic Feats that occult casters can use to ignore some spellcasting components.
Emotion components replace a psychic spell's somatic components. Logical Spell lets you cast without emotion components, analogous to Still Spell bypassing a spell's somatic components.
Thought components replace verbal components, and this is why defensive spellcasting is very tricky for an occult caster. Intuitive Spell lets you cast without thought components, analogous to Silent Spell bypassing a spell's verbal components.
This +10 increase in DC applies in any scenario when a caster needs to make a concentration check: casting defensively, being grappled, taking damage, being on a moving surface, being in bad weather, and so on. Unlike a wizard, a psychic may attempt to cast while pinned, although they need to succeed a rather difficult concentration DC to do so.
Emotion/thought components do not "qualify as" verbal/somatic components. So your GM's reasoning is in conflict with the RAW. When using the Cunning Caster feat, a psychic spellcaster should not take the -4 penalty (or penalties), because their spells don't involve somatic or verbal components.
However, even without verbal/somatic components, psychic spellcasting is assumed to be noticeable. The caster would need to make the Bluff check.