[RPG] Is the Shield Master shove the same as normal shoving other than the action timing

actionsdnd-5efeats

Reading the Shield Master feat:

If you take the Attack action on your turn, you can use a bonus action
to try to shove a creature within 5 feet of you with your shield.

So I can shove as a bonus action.

Now normally shove takes part of an attack:

Using the Attack action, you can make a special melee attack to shove
a creature, either to knock it prone or push it away from you. If
you’re able to make multiple attacks with the Attack action, this
attack replaces one of them.

Am I right in thinking that these are the same; so the choice is if I prefer to spend part of an attack vs using a bonus action? Mechanically is there a difference?

By extension could I say that anyone with lots of bonus action options probably won't want Shield Master?

Best Answer

The action cost is different, but the effect is the same

Shield Master lets you shove without sacrificing an attack

Normally, when a character takes the Attack action, they can replace any of the attacks they get with a Shove action. Shoving in this way involves the sacrifice of one attack.

With Shield Master, the character need not sacrifice any of their attacks when they take an Attack action. Instead, they can shove using a bonus action.

They are very different things. A character who gets only one attack as part of an Attack action must give up all their attacks to shove someone. That is a significant sacrifice. Getting the same action as a bonus action means that one need not make that sacrifice. Which is a distinct advantage if that is something that the character is doing on a regular basis.

Effects of the shove are the same

Regardless of the actions used to take it, the character is still taking the Shove action. As such, the effects of the Shove are exactly the same.

Also, note that having Shield Master does not prevent you from taking the normal shove action (replacing one of your attacks) it just gives you and additional option. You could even do both in the same turn if you wanted (including shoving even before you attack).

Bonus actions are valuable

If you are playing a character that makes heavy use of their bonus actions for things other than Shield Master, then this part of Shield Master is probably not going to be the most useful to you. You only get one bonus action per turn and it is good to spend it wisely. However, not all characters do have a bonus action ability that they use commonly. In this case, if one wants to shove, this allows that character to put that bonus action to good use. In the end it all comes down to the specific character build you have/want to have.