The general setting:
- I want to play a rogue.
- My party needs me in melee.
- I want to choose the Arcane Trickster archetype.
- XGtE and SCAG are allowed.
I am aware that these basic assumptions conflict with the common consensus about strict optimization of a rogue, so we are talking about optimization under constraints, of course.
The primary objective is to build this character in a such a way that its most important mechanic, the Sneak Attack, can be exploited as efficiently as possible: Maximize sneak damage by enhancing the opportunities to sneak (on- and off-turn) and the probability to actually hit.
The main advantage a melee rogue has over a ranged rogue is that the former is more likely to use the reaction for off-turn Sneak Attacks. This is why my character will be a Human (variant) and take Sentinel as his starting feat. I will also use dual-wielding so that in case of a miss, I can sacrifice my bonus action for a second chance to hit. The main disadvantage of a melee rogue over a ranged rogue is that frontline survivability becomes an issue. This is secondary to my build, though. My current "defense plan" is the following: High dexterity plus Mage Armor give a decent AC, Uncanny Dodge and Evasion provide good defensive abilities, and choosing spells like Mirror Image or Blur will also help. I am open for comments on that and further suggestions anyway, but more in view of combat strategies than abilities.
The general question: In view of my main objective, are there obvious ways to go from there in terms of multiclassing that are demonstrably optimal or at least superior to a singleclass character? This is of course a question of balance: Apart from finding ways which help in using Sneak Attacks, the main difficulty is to determine whether the pay off is worth sacrificing rogue levels (and hence Sneak Attack dice).
Doing three to five levels of Fighter Battlemaster or two to six of Wizard Bladesinger (my DM is okay with relaxing the elf requirement) seem like a good place to look for me. But maybe someone has already done the math and can give a more or less definite answer?
Other things to consider:
- The campaign starts at level 1 and is intended to eventually go all the way up to level 20.
- The rest of the party consists of a Barbarian Dwarf who's going to be our tank and who will usually be right next to me in the frontline (enabling me to use Sneak Attack), a Human Bard focusing on buffs (duh) and fluff, and a Gnome Wizard who likes any spell that incorporates fire (but who will also likely provide me with Mage Armor). Possible strategies that need working together are of course welcome. However, the others probably won't think of their characters as mere assistants to mine. 😉
- The DM plans to provide magic items according to the suggestions in the DMG.
- I am looking more for a dip (no more than around five levels) than for an even multiclass.
- I am not opposed to combining more than two classes, unless the resulting build would heavily violate the above point.
Best Answer
The best choice depends on the situation.
Unfortunately there is no clear winner, so you'll have to weigh the pros and cons. I only included dips (when you pick up a few levels in a class, this is in contrast to builds that split more evenly) and only dual-class multiclassing. It is possible that the best build for your specific campaign and playstyle is a mixture of three or more classes, but this should provide some idea of what benefit you gain from each class.
To start with, we need a baseline to compare to.
Pure Rogue
As a pure rogue, these are the ranges available to you:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 4&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&7&\text{3d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{4d6}\\ 8&2&8&\text{4d6}\\ 9&2&9&\text{5d6}\\ 11&2&9&\text{6d6}\\ 13&2&10&\text{7d6}\\ 15&2&10&\text{8d6}\\ 17&2&11&\text{9d6}\\ 19&2&11&\text{10d6}\\ \end{array}$$
There is no multiclassing option that can keep up with the Sneak Attack damage here (save perhaps Champion fighter or Hexblade warlock if you can get Advantage often and score critical hits). The reason to multiclass is to increase the Number of Chances to hit or the To-hit Bonus.
Also, staying as a pure Rogue gives you the capstone level 20 ability that guarantees a hit once between short rests.
Now let's look at the options you suggest...
Bladesinger 2
The Bladesinger does not provide any bonuses to the to-hit bonus, the Sneak Attack damage, or the number of chances to hit, but it does increase your ability to maintain concentration on haste. As such, the best time to invest in Bladesinger is after level 13 when you gain access to level 3 spells as an Arcane Trickster. As such, you get this new table:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 4&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&7&\text{3d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{4d6}\\ 8&2&8&\text{4d6}\\ 9&2&9&\text{5d6}\\ 11&2&9&\text{6d6}\\ 13&2&10&\text{7d6}\\ 15&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{7d6}\\ 17&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{8d6}\\ 19&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{9d6}\\ \end{array}$$
Whether it is worth it to slow down your progression into Rogue to increase your ability to maintain Concentration on haste is something you'd have to decide. Bladesinger and haste also add Intelligence and 2 to your AC respectively.
Bladesinger 5
Alternatively, you could grab haste much earlier from the wizard class. If you collect the wizard levels immediately after becoming an Arcane Trickster, you get this table:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{2d6}\\ 8&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&7&\text{2d6}\\ 9&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&9&\text{2d6}\\ 10&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&9&\text{3d6}\\ 12&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&9&\text{4d6}\\ 13&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{4d6}\\ 14&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{5d6}\\ 16&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{6d6}\\ 17&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{6d6}\\ 18&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{7d6}\\ 20&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{8d6}\\ \end{array}$$
This option is useful if you expect to be up against the occasional enemy that is very hard to hit (in which case the extra attack from haste is more valuable than the extra damage on only 2 attacks that you might miss), and you don't expect to need the extra damage from Sneak Attack against those enemies that aren't hard to hit.
Bladesinger 6
Putting one more level into Bladesinger gives you Extra Attack, but severely delays the Sneak Attack damage. You get this table:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{2d6}\\ 8&\text{2 (3 during } haste\text{)}&7&\text{2d6}\\ 9&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&8&\text{2d6}\\ 10&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&9&\text{2d6}\\ 11&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&9&\text{3d6}\\ 13&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{4d6}\\ 15&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&10&\text{5d6}\\ 17&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{6d6}\\ 19&\text{3 (4 during } haste\text{)}&11&\text{7d6}\\ \end{array}$$
This is a good option if the Extra Attack feature is meaningful. Some cases for this include if you are up against a lot of enemies with high armor classes, and if it is beneficial for a magic weapon you collect.
Fighter 2
The reason to dip into Fighter with your criteria would be for Action Surge. Action Surge is very similar in this case to the reason haste is used. Extra chances against hard to hit enemies. However, you can pick it up much sooner than haste, but it doesn't provide its benefit for multiple rounds. Here's the table:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&6&\text{2d6}\\ 6&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&7&\text{2d6}\\ 7&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&7&\text{3d6}\\ 9&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&8&\text{4d6}\\ 10&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&9&\text{4d6}\\ 11&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&9&\text{5d6}\\ 13&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&10&\text{6d6}\\ 15&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&10&\text{7d6}\\ 17&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&11&\text{8d6}\\ 19&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&11&\text{9d6}\\ \end{array}$$
This is better than the haste options in Bladesinger in that it requires less investment or levels to reach the extra attack chance, but you get less extra attacks overall. As such, it is best with high AC, but low HP enemies (or if an extra action matters for some other reason). Fighter also grants proficiency in shields if you decide you'd prefer the extra AC to the extra attack with your second weapon. Additionally, if you start with 1 level of fighter, you could have heavy armor proficiency.
Fighter 5
Similar to Bladesinger 6, this is a choice to go for Extra Attack. It requires one less level than the Bladesinger option, and results in the table below.
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&6&\text{2d6}\\ 7&\text{2 (3 with Action Surge)}&7&\text{2d6}\\ 8&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&7&\text{2d6}\\ 9&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&9&\text{2d6}\\ 10&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&9&\text{3d6}\\ 12&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&9&\text{4d6}\\ 13&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&10&\text{4d6}\\ 14&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&10&\text{5d6}\\ 16&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&10&\text{6d6}\\ 17&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&11&\text{6d6}\\ 18&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&11&\text{7d6}\\ 20&\text{3 (4 with Action Surge)}&11&\text{8d6}\\ \end{array}$$
I didn't include Subclass because there are four choices which all have their own pros and cons.
Now let's get into the ones you didn't list...
Barbarian 2-5
Barbarian is a possible option for a similar reason that Samurai is appealing. Reckless Attack lets you gain advantage at-will (albeit at the cost of granting your foes advantage against you). It follows the same table as the Fighter 2, but without Action Surge. Also, keep in mind, you have to use Strength as your primary ability score to benefit from Reckless Attack.
You can also carry Barbarian to level 5 to gain Extra Attack just like with Fighter, but the subclasses don't provide any boon to your criteria. I'd choose Ancestral Guardian to counteract the Advantage you may grant as a result of Reckless Attack. Barbarian also grants Unarmored Defense letting you add your Constitution to your armor class when wearing no armor. You also gain proficiency in shields from Barbarian in case you want to get +2 AC at the cost of one of your attacks.
War Cleric 2
Undergoing some devotion to the War Domain grants you a Channel Divinity that adds 10 to an attack roll. This can let you hit vital Sneak Attacks throughout the day. Otherwise this build follows the same table as the Fighter 2. The War Domain also offers proficiency in heavy armor.
Vengeance Paladin 3
The Paladin of the Oath of Vengeance has a Channel Divinity that allows you to gain advantage, and as such, has similar benefits to the Barbarian's Reckless Attack or the Samurai's Fighting Spirit. It follows the following table (as would going for just Fighter 3 for the subclasses, except add Action Surge for Fighter):
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{2d6}\\ 8&2&7&\text{3d6}\\ 9&2&8&\text{3d6}\\ 10&2&8&\text{4d6}\\ 11&2&9&\text{4d6}\\ 12&2&9&\text{5d6}\\ 13&2&10&\text{5d6}\\ 14&2&10&\text{6d6}\\ 16&2&10&\text{7d6}\\ 17&2&11&\text{7d6}\\ 18&2&11&\text{8d6}\\ 20&2&11&\text{9d6}\\ \end{array}$$
Obviously you could carry Paladin to level 5 to grab Extra Attack and get the same progression as Fighter 5 (but without Action Surge). Paladin offers similar defensive bonuses that Fighter does.
Vengeance Paladin or Fighter 4
In the above case, you could also grab one more level in the paladin or fighter class to get the ability score increase earlier at the cost of a delayed Rogue progression. That results in the following table (add Action Surge for Fighter)
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 7&2&7&\text{2d6}\\ 8&2&8&\text{2d6}\\ 9&2&9&\text{3d6}\\ 11&2&9&\text{4d6}\\ 13&2&10&\text{5d6}\\ 15&2&10&\text{6d6}\\ 17&2&11&\text{7d6}\\ 19&2&11&\text{8d6}\\ \end{array}$$
Ranger 3-5
Ranger follows the same progressions as Paladin and Fighter 3-5, but with the following changes depending on subclass:
Hexblade 1-5
If you expect to be able to get Advantage often, you can delay your Rogue progress by only 1 level to double the number of counts on the d20 that result in critical hits. This is done by grabbing one level of Warlock with the Hexblade patron. It's probably best to take after level 5 so the critical hits hurt that much more. A 1-level dip at level 6 results in this table:
$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{Level}&\text{Number of Chances}&\text{To-Hit Bonus}&\text{Damage}\\ 1&2&5&\text{1d6}\\ 3&2&5&\text{2d6}\\ 4&2&6&\text{2d6}\\ 5&2&7&\text{3d6}\\ 8&2&7&\text{4d6}\\ 9&2&9&\text{4d6}\\ 10&2&9&\text{5d6}\\ 12&2&9&\text{6d6}\\ 13&2&10&\text{6d6}\\ 14&2&10&\text{7d6}\\ 16&2&10&\text{8d6}\\ 17&2&11&\text{8d6}\\ 18&2&11&\text{9d6}\\ 20&2&11&\text{10d6}\\ \end{array}$$
You could go a bit further into Hexblade (to level 3) to get the Improved Pact Weapon invocation, which turns one weapon into a +1 magic weapon. This is better if you do not expect to get a magic finesse weapon by around level 6 (which is fairly unlikely using DMG guidelines). It follows the same progression as the other 3-dips, but all but your Two-Weapon Fighting attack gets an additional +1 on the To-Hit Bonus.
After that, you can take Hexblade to level 5 for Thirsting Blade (an extra attack) just like you would Fighter, Paladin, or Ranger. Hexblade also gives you proficiency in shields. See Fighter and Barbarian for details on how this can help with your defensive capacity.
Conclusion
As you can see, every class has something to offer when optimizing for Sneak Attack damage and chances to hit. No one build beats out any other, so you just have to pick and choose what your priorities are. Here are some general notes though: