Is there an equivalent of the Infinite Scrollcase from Magic of Eberron in Pathfinder. In particular I'm looking for an item that stores multiple scrolls and allows a caster to more easily access the desired scroll?
[RPG] Pathfinder Equivalent of Infinite Scrollcase
eberronmagic-itemspathfinder-1e
Related Solutions
I like the idea, but it's too rich.
You're basically saying a 1 HD creature is worth 75 gp equivalent value (as it's one to one to gp when used to make magic items), so it needs to give 75 gp less in cash money. Refer to the Pathfinder treasure value per encounter guidelines.
Let's compare against the example they use of an EL10 encounter with an 8 HD stone giant and 4 4 HD gargoyles. If you're using the medium pace that encounter should be worth 4250 gp. It looks like using your rules the PCs can soul-trap 4800 + 1200 + 1200 + 1200 + 1200 = 9600 septims, which is way high. I might discount it a little because of the need to cast the spell, but especially as the spell has no save I'd personally bring along a level 1 goon with a bunch of scrolls I've scribed for him to get the sweet, sweet free money. Even if they just trap the giant, that's more than the gp value that the encounter should provide - and that's with zero treasure over and above the soul.
Because face it, magic is the #1 use of money in games after a certain level - so I wouldn't discount it all that much.
What you need to do is match up "soul value" those charts in the PRD so you're not giving a huge windfall.
Pitfalls of unlimited magic item creation:
Well, under a system like Pathfinder that doesn't charge XP for magic item creation, unlimited creation coupled with a free magic item market where things can be sold for market value provides a very easy way to generate lots of cash. At the very least, it lets you increase party wealth massively over standard wealth by level. We tried removing XP costs from crafting in 3.5 once, and by about 9th level we had twice as much magic gear as we should've.
Then there's the verisimilitude issue. Who makes all this crap? Why did some wizard spend 200 days out of his life making just this perfect +4 keen vorpal kama, investing 100000 gp worth of materials into a product for which there is a terribly limited demand? Why didn't he hire a company of pikemen and set himself up as a wizard king of some significant region of countryside with that money instead? Effectively, as a player and a GM, unlimited magic item purchasing freedom breaks my suspension of disbelief unless some very fast talking is done on a very regular basis. Eberron is one place where I might buy it because of the volume of artificers and magewrights and whatnot; not familiar enough with the Realms or Golarion to pass judgment there.
Consequences of restriction
Really where restrictions hit hardest is saving throws. There are lots of buffs that boost to-hit and let you punch through DR as though your weapon were magical; the options for general saves are rather more limited. Coming out of a 13th-level campaign where there were no Cloaks of Resistance to be had, I can tell you that it's a sad day when the pitiful 0th-level Resistance is a staple buff of 13th level characters (that and Protection from Evil, if we knew what we were going up against). But it was absolutely clutch to have; we went up against a bodak around 9th level, and I was the only one who bothered putting up Resistance and drinking a potion of Bear's Endurance. I was also the only survivor. Bad saves scale much more slowly than monster save DCs, and Cloaks of Resistance save lives. So, by opting for non-purchasable magic items, you can increase campaign lethality significantly. This may be desirable.
Additionally, if you keep handing out gold, players will be at a loss for what to do with it all. Then they'll start bribing magistrates and hiring mercenaries and buying ships and building castles and otherwise using money to interact with the world in a manner other than "buy these things that make my numbers better". If these are behaviors you wish to encourage, then restricting magic item purchases will help you achieve this end.
Kinds of games which benefit from unlimited magic item availability
Arguably, adventure-path type games and similar plot-heavy railroads benefit from it. Games where you don't want PCs dying left and right, and where you don't really want PCs to go out of their way to interact with the world (because that would damage plot), and where you likewise don't particularly care about the economic ramifications of allowing infinite availability. Combat As Sport games, where you want their numbers to be juuust right for them to fight your lovingly crafted encounters and not die. If that's the type of game you play, then unlimited availability is a great idea. It keeps everybody happy, and you don't end up with that one guy with the +4 sword that you rolled on the treasure tables while everybody else has +1.
Despite this, I still prefer to play and run games with limited magic item availability. If someone wants a Holy Avenger, they better go find a library and figure out what dungeon they can find one in, because they don't just have a rack of 'em at the general store. This generates player-driven quests, which I find to be generally more fun than DM-driven quests (be it via NPCs or circumstances). Likewise, I like my games reasonably-lethal, sans fixed plot and with as much player involvement with the setting as I can muster. Making magic items freely available for purchase at market price stifles all of these things.
Best Answer
Actually, there is a handy substitution.
Bag, Handy Haversack can store much more than Infinite Scrollcase's 50 scrolls, gets the scroll out as the same move action, does not provoke an AoO either in doing so and is priced at 2000 gp vs 2800 gp.
If you feel fancy, you can retrieve the scroll in question with the help of an Unseen Servant.
As an added benefit, you can store anything you like there.