[RPG] Sword of Sharpness Critical Hit Resolution

critical-hitdnd-5emagic-items

The Sword of Sharpness states:

When you attack an object with this magic sword and hit, maximize your weapon damage dice against the target.

It also has a secondary feature:

When you attack a creature with this weapon and roll a 20 on the attack roll, that target takes an extra 4d6 slashing damage.

1) Would these extra 4d6 damage dice also be maximized in damage (ie just add 24 damage)?

I also play as a level 20 half orc Barbarian, meaning that when I land a critical:

  • Thanks to Brutal Critical I am able to add 3 additional damage dice.
  • Thanks to the Savage Attacks class feature, I can add an additional damage die.

2) Would these 4 additional critical dice also be maximized in damage?

While I'm not sure about question 1, I think question 2 would be yes. Since critical hits use the damage dice of the weapon, and since on a hit the weapon's damage dice are maximized, I don't see why critical dice would not also be maximized.

But some clarification on both of these questions would definitely be appreciated.

Best Answer

No, these 2 abilities can never work together.

When you attack an object...

vs

When you attack a creature...

The DMG defines objects on page 246 as:

...an object is a discrete, inanimate item like a window, door, sword, book, table, chair, or stone...