[RPG] the affinity between ghosts and the ethereal

dnd-5eplanes

In D&D cosmology, we learn that the Ethereal connects the Material to the Inner Planes (Elemental, Feywild, Shadow, etc) and that the Astral connects to the Outer Planes (Gods and afterlives stuff). We also learn that a ghost is a soul that is 'tethered' to the Material for some reason or another to prevent its trip to the afterlife.

So why are they the most populous and iconic inhabitants of the space between mortality (Material) and ….fire salamanders (Elemental)? Is it easier to travel from Material to Ethereal to Astral to the Outer Planes, and thus that's the way dead souls are 'sucked'? The ability to see the living seems useful to a ghost and there have been vague references to the ectoplasm of the Ethereal being connected to 'memory' somehow (which might be thematic if it wasn't so vague), but why is the 'backstage' where raw materials are turned into the Prime Material the iconic place where post-material souls hang out instead of the Astral?

Best Answer

It’s simply because anything that is present, but incorporeal, on the material plane by definition exists partly in the Border Ethereal. An entity like a ghost, that is tethered to the material plane but has an incorporeal portion, has that part in the plane that is — definitionally — where incorporeal parts of material plane entities exist.

That’s the role of the ethereal plane: being the transition plane between the material and everything else in the planar cosmos. It isn’t primarily the place where “raw materials are turned into the Prime Material”: it only happens to also be that because its foremost nature is being the medium through which the inner planes connect, in both directions.

By contrast, the astral is not adjacent to the material plane, so it’s not a candidate for ghosts’ incorporeal portions. Travelling to the astral plane “naturally” — without portals or spells that take you there — requires passing through the ethereal first. Ghosts are trapped in the border ethereal and can’t even reach the rest of the ethereal plane, because they can’t fully leave the material plane. They certainly can’t reach edge of the ethereal where it meets the astral, and its access to an afterlife in the outer planes.