[RPG] use the Mirage Arcane spell to walk on top of a stretch of ocean

dnd-5eillusionspells

I'm not entirely sure how to ask this question since this spell starts bending reality in ways that are difficult for me to envision. To be fair, though, that's kind of the point.

This answer posits that the illusion created by the mirage arcane spell is not real and entirely superficial. I'm not sure, but it seems like this runs contrary to the notion that the spell creates tactile elements which makes me think that you could push off the illusion (which isn't unheard of for shadow illusions from 3.5).

The spell's range is "sight" and it can affect "terrain in an area up to 1 square mile", which depending how you shape it, can be incredibly long. Were I to only make it 10' wide, I could run that out for 528 miles (assuming I could see that far away).

My questions:

  • Ignoring the feasibility of seeing that far, could a Wizard use this
    spell to create the illusion of a smooth path across a stretch of
    raging ocean to permit the party to walk overland between continents?
  • Do the party members who believe the illusion walk upon the strip of
    land, enjoying the safety of the land? If so, do they move slower
    than they think they should? Assume none of them have a swim speed.
  • Or do they fall through the illusion and start drowning? Do they even
    realize they are drowning? If so, when would they realize that?

Best Answer

Although I agree with the answer from cpcodes, I think it could be made clearer so I'll make an attempt.

The crux of the question is quite simple: does a "tactile" illusion include the ability to support weight? Clearly a tactile illusion could make metal feel like stone, but if an entire illusory object were tactile could you stand on it? It's possible that this isn't consistent, but Jeremy Crawford, the lead Rules Designer for D&D, has this to say:

You can climb an illusory tree formed by mirage arcane.

While this isn't strictly identical to the proposed use of the spell, it is entirely unambiguous that mirage arcane is capable of producing illusions that support weight, and thus I conclude that an "illusion" of solid ground could be crossed regardless of what the "real" terrain was. All indications I can find are that creatures treat such terrain as if it were real regardless of any ability to "know" that it's not, and thus move at normal speeds.

As for making the affected area into a long path, I don't think that's possible. First of all, the spells I can find with malleable areas are quite explicit about it, but additionally the spell description does not say "one square mile". Instead it says:

an area up to 1 mile square

"1 mile square" more closely follows the phrasing of areas like "20ft square", which I have never seen interpreted as "any shape with an area of 20 square feet", and instead it always means "a square shaped area with sides 20 feet long". This could have been made more explicit (using wording from some other spells, "an area contained within a 1 mile square" would be clearer), but I don't believe you could make a rectangle 2 miles long and 0.5 miles wide let alone a narrow 10 foot path 528 miles long.

You could still cross oceans with it because it isn't a concentration spell, but you will need to either:

  • cast it a lot more than you might have planned
  • be a School of Illusion Wizard (PHB p. 118) of 6th level or above - which would give you access to the Malleable Illusions feature:

    Starting at 6th level, when you cast an illusion spell that has a duration of 1 minute or longer, you can use your action to change the nature of that illusion (using the spell's normal parameters for the illusion), provided that you can see the illusion.

    This feature would allow you to, on getting to the end of your 1-mile illusory land bridge, alter the mirage arcane spell so that the land bridge now starts from where you are, and continues out to sea. Rinse and repeat for as many miles as you want to cross.