[RPG] What does a Troglodyte actually smell like

adnd-1emonsters

In 1st Edition AD&D, the Monster Manual states that Troglodytes

…emit a secretion which smells
extremely disgusting to humans…

If I want to keep the party on their toes, I would like to say something like, "As you approach the entrance to the cavern, you smell a strong odor, reeking of ZZZZZ and ZZZZZ", instead of just saying, "Hey, you smell trogs around the corner!"

Has anyone read one of those 'Ecology of…' articles that might describe in more detail the particular odor of the troglodyte secretion?

I can always make something up, but I'd prefer not to contradict existing literature if it exists.

Best Answer

According to "Ecology of the Troglodyte" in Dragon #235, it's not that they stink per se, but that they use scent to communicate.

...the overpowering stench that can reduce a human opponent to weak-kneed vomiting during combat with troglodyte, is merely the build up of olfactory battle cries, combat orders, screams of rage, pain, and hunger, and other smell/phrases which are spoken/emitted in such profusion that the combined smell overpowers non-troglodyte.

The scents they describe are many and varied; in fact the name of the trog in the piece is "Rose-Boiled Cabbage-Mild Skunk" as his name is a mix of those scents. But to the average human, more than one or two scents at a time just smell like "stank."