Okay, let's assume that a non-shapeshifter (Bob the human for example) is going to be polymorphed (Using True Polymorph) into a werewolf. What would be the most likely thing to happen?
- Would Bob be stuck in wolf or hybrid form for the spell's duration?
- Would Bob temporarily have lycanthropy for the spell's duration? (i.e. he can use his true, hybrid, or wolf form at will, unless a full moon or other trigger is active, then Bob is stuck in hybrid or wolf form)
- Would Bob be a lycanthrope after the polymorph is over because he can't be affected by shapeshifting magic now that he is now a shapeshifter?
- Would polymophing something into a shapeshifter be impossible (or create a magical paradox that destroys the planes of existence)?
Best Answer
Yes you can turn into a lycanthrope
True Polymorph enables the character to be polymorphed into any creature.
The relevant portions of the True Polymorph spell are:
In order to fulfil these criteria we have to answer three questions:
Is the target of the spell a shapechanger?
Assuming you are targeting a player character then the answer to this question will generally be No. (The DM will know if this is not the case.)
Are lycanthropes creatures?
Yes
The Monster Manual provides the following text:
From this piece of text we can see they are creatures.
In addition to this the Monster Manual gives suggested stat blocks for example lycanthropes (based on humans). In those stat blocks they include the creature types:
It also states that non-human lycanthropes are a valid variant, but that the stat blocks may need some tweaking to account for the various racial features non-human lycanthropes may have.
Will the result of the spell be a creature with the lycanthropy curse?
Yes
The relevant True Polymorph quote here is:
The curse of lycanthropy is a game statistic of the chosen creature the target is being polymorphed into.
The Monster Manual provides only two ways for this curse to be removed:
If True Polymorph (or a similar spell) removed the curse then it would invalidate the limitations specified in the MM for natural born lycanthropes, namely the potential for the caster of wish, wishing to remove the curse, suffering the stress which removes their access to wish going forward.
If that spell is being used then they get all of the stats of the lycanthrope they are being polymorphed into. This includes all of the lycanthropes normal shape-shifting abilities.
What happens while they are True Polymorphed?
While they are under the effects of the True Polymorph spell with this choice the character is no longer a valid target for any further castings of Polymorph and True Polymorph.
Can they control the shapechanging ability?
Up to the DM
The ability to control the shapechanging is limited to those creatures who have accepted the curse:
As a result the DM has an interpretation choice: - The caster must specify this in advance, and if the caster does not then the target can't control the shapechange - The newly polymorphed character has to accept the curse and learn how to control their new form (with the relevant penalties).
Note: A will here means that they would be able to choose to stay in their humanoid form during a full moon.
If they can't control the shapechanging ability are they stuck in the hybrid/animal form?
Unlikely unless a very specific set of circumstances are met.
The effects of True Polymorph can potentially last indefinitely.
If the caster did not specify and the DM has chosen to interpret the change in the relevant way, then the criteria for having the hybrid form manifest are specified in the Monster Manual:
Taking all this into account, then if a full moon occurs while the character is under the effects of the True Polymorph spell then the target will be in the animal/hybrid version of their new form while that full moon is in effect.
Assuming they are only True Polymorphed while a full moon is out, then yes, otherwise no.
Sidebar In order to not limit or punish player creativity it would be adviseable to let the player be in control of the animal/hybrid form's actions while transformed (even if they can't control when the transformation takes effect).
What happens when the spell ends?
Once the spell ends the character reverts to their normal stat block.
Side Note: The basic Polymorph only allows you to be turned into a beast. Lycanthropes in the Monster Manual have the type “Humanoid” and do not have the type “Beast”. As a result they are not a valid creature to be polymorphed into.