In trying to give credit where it's due, I'd like to learn the name or pseudonym of the originator of the Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle (DCFS) (link is to a definition not a source), and where and when both concept and term first appeared. Shockingly, the DCFS doesn't appear on this Optimization Timeline, and given the June 2006 publication date of Fiendish Codex I, the DCFS must've existed before March 2008, which is the earliest I can find mention of it.
[RPG] When, where, and with whom did the Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle originate
dnd-3.5ehistory-of-gamingspells
Related Topic
- [RPG] Where did the term BBEG come from
- [RPG] Where and when did “the GM is always right” get codified first
- [RPG] Where did the first Dungeons and Dragons miniatures come from
- [RPG] Where and when did “Have Fun” enter the gaming books
- [RPG] Where did the concept of community copies originate in the indie scene
- When did the Dungeons and Dragons Insider service exist
Best Answer
Known History of the DCFS
Using Embrace- and Shun the Dark Chaos in succession, which combination allows a character to replace any feat they currently have with any feat they currently qualify for, appears to have struck some optimizers fairly quickly after the Fiendish Codex I was published. The first poster I found was HotSake, but he was actually beaten to the punch, and with more complete understanding of the utility of the combo by Zemyla. Zemyla specified that '...you can replace any feats you have...', which described that feats of all sorts are fair game.
As for using the combo for replacing a feat that you can somehow regain for a nominal cost, such as time, I first found skydragonknight's combo, which was also preceded by Sinfire Titan's combo.
(4/16/2017) The first usage of the term dark Chaos Feat Shuffle the I've found is by Wizard Random, with archerpwr using 'FC1 feat shuffle' about the same time.
So Zemyla announced the first reading of how to replace unnecessary feats with the DCFS, and Sinfire Titan appears to have boasted of the first repetitious replacing of a feat or feats via DCFS.
The Posts, in the Order Discovered
I don't fully recall if I read this first thread when the WotC 339 board still lived, as I was very new at looking for mechanical advantage at the time (I vaguely recall it, but none of the later ones personally), but this initially appeared to be the earliest reference to combining the two spells for their unintended consequences.
Better than retraining feats, at the cost of your soul.
However, a week earlier, this thread said the same thing:
Nonpsionic Reformation!
Zemyla specified '...any feats you have...', and Chaos116882 explained to Tleilaxu_Ghola why it trumps Retraining.
This was originally the earliest I found explicitly for 'Infinite Feats' using DCFS:
Another Way to Get Infinite Feats?
But in this thread, 4 days previously, Sinfire Titan boasted, then delivered:
Book of Nine Swords - My God! What have they done???
New findings (4/16/2017)
archerpwr mentioned 'FC1 feat shuffle' in passing:
n00b to epic. Help me make a gish?
and Wizard Random mentioned 'the Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle' by name:
4 round Timeless Body, is it worth it?
Unfortunately, it looks like this was a known title, because nobody asked what it was or commented that it was a good name. Its usage is almost a year after Zemyla's noting of the utility of the combo, but I've found no earlier uses of the phrase.