[RPG] Why would I choose anything other than a Greataxe as the Warlock Pact weapon

class-featurednd-5eoptimizationwarlockweapons

In the PHB p.107 on Pact of the Blade boon it is stated:

You can choose the form that this melee
weapon takes each time you create it (see chapter 5 for
weapon options). You are proficient with it while you
wield it.

Why would I ever choose a "low" damage weapon, compared to a Greataxe (for example) with its 1d12 damage? I'll be proficient with whatever weapon I choose, anyway.

Best Answer

There's no reason to deliberately choose low damage weapons, but there are plenty of weapons that might be better than a greataxe sometimes:

  • the two-handed sword deals more damage on average than the greataxe (2d6 is more than 1d12)
  • you might be fighting something that cares about your damage type -- for example, a skeleton is vulnerable to bludgeoning damage, so you should prefer a maul which deals 2d6 bludgeoning
  • you might be underwater and want a piercing weapon
  • you might prefer a reach weapon sometimes, despite the lower damage
  • you might be on a horse, and want a lance
  • you might have a Dexterity-based character who prefers a finesse weapon
  • you might want to make a ranged attack, and a thrown melee weapon will do that
  • you might need a one-handed weapon (for two-weapon fighting, or for sword-and-shield fighting, or if you need a hand for climbing, etc.)