[RPG] Would Shriekers prevent someone from hearing Harpies

dnd-5e

A few people climb a mountain, finally reaching a safe tunnel for the night.

Upon entry, a few Shriekers start screeching. That alarms the Harpies that live on the other side of the tunnel. The Harpies immediately decide to start singing.

Is that a valid scenario or would the screeching be so loud that the characters would anyway not hear the Harpies' songs?

Best Answer

Shriekers do not prevent creatures from hearing anything. There is a Deafened condition in Appendix A of the PHB; if Shriekers were meant to make it impossible to hear anything, they would give creatures this condition.

The Harpy's Luring Song, like the Shrieker's Shriek, is audible within 300 ft. You're free to rule however you choose, of course, but as far as the book is concerned, any creature within 300 feet of the Harpy that hasn't lost its hearing somehow can be affected by Luring Song.