Learn English – “has been opened ” or “being opened”

present-perfectprogressive-aspect

  1. The door of the refrigerator being opened by 90 degrees or less is closed automatically if you let go of the door.
  2. The door of the refrigerator that has been opened by 90 degrees or less is closed automatically if you let go of the door.

I would like to know which sounds natural and correct. I think the second may imply as if the door was not able to be closed.

Best Answer

The first is ungrammatical. Just strike being and by and it's OK.

The second is grammatical.

You want to describe the actual achieved state of the door which triggers the automatic close.

The refrigerator door (when) open|opened to 90 degrees or less closes automatically when you let go of it.

I think open is preferable to opened here.