Learn English – How to resolve ambiguous meanings. Especially, “stand” and “stand up”. And, are there alternatives

ambiguitymeaning-in-contextphrasal-verbssynonymsword-usage

1 – How to resolve ambiguity of "stand".

First, my main question is how to resolve and work with the ambiguity of the verb "stand". It's ambiguous in a sense that it can mean both "to be in a standing position" and "to get into a standing position". For instance, the following are ambiguous:

  • "Everyone stood when the President came in" (Was everyone already standing before the President came in or did everyone stand only after the President came in?)
  • "Some people stood for the opening of the guest speaker's speech." (Did the people stand up for the opening of the speech, or did they stand up and remain standing for the duration, or did they simply remain standing for the opening?)

Am I correct in my thinking above? And how, in general, does one know which meaning is intended, or how does one write such that the meaning is unambiguous?

2 Synonyms for Stand? And is there ambiguity issues there too?

Secondarily, I'm looking for some choices to describe "being in" or "getting into" a standing position, but I want to be careful about potential ambiguity. Towards this effort, I have researched and come across the following:

  • I read that "stand up" can have both of these meanings and it's also thus ambiguous.
  • Can the phrases "get up" and "get to one's feet" mean both "being in" and "getting into a standing position"?
  • As I understand it, "rise" is unambiguous, meaning "to get into a standing position" and not "to be in a standing position"
  • Any other synonyms / phrases I could use?

Am I correct in my research above? Are there other similar words or phrases that mean either "being in" or "getting into" a standing position that I can use without the inherent ambiguity?


I welcome any kind of clarification of how to deal with this kind of ambiguity: specifically in regards to stand and it's synonyms, or some more general rule that would cover this and other cases.

Best Answer

Generally, when "stand" is used to mean "is in a standing position", it is accompanied by a location:

He stood in the corner, sipping a whiskey.

They stood around the table, arguing.

She stood by the window, looking forlornly down the empty driveway.

Often this meaning will be expressed in the past continuous, using "was standing" instead of "stood" to unambiguously refer to the condition of standing, as opposed to the act of standing:

He was standing in the corner, sipping a whiskey.

When "stand" is used to mean "get to one's feet", it is either unaccompanied, or accompanied by an event:

He stood when she entered the room.

They stood as the speaker finished his speech.

"Now that you're here, I can finally leave," she said as she stood.

In my experience, stand up is rarely used for "be in a standing position" when it refers to a person; you are much more likely to hear it used for an inanimate object (especially one which is normally horizontal), and again it will most likely be accompanied by a location:

The bedframe stood up against the wall.

Most often, stand up is used for the action of getting to one's feet:

He stood up and stretched

As I approached, he stood up and reached to shake my hand.

Everyone stood up when the orchestra finished its song.

In your first two examples, people changed from sitting to standing when the president came in, and people changed from sitting to standing for the opening of the speech (they did not remain standing for the entire speech, but sat down again after only a moment or two).

Your given alternatives, "get to one's feet" and "rise", both unambiguously refer to the action of changing from a non-standing position into a standing position.

Related Topic