Verbs – What Does ‘Ask a Question’ Mean?

#quotationsgerundsspoken-englishverbs

Should the "ask" be in an "ing" form? Consider the following conversation,

A: I think I can ask a question on Stack Exchange.
B: What do you mean by ask a question?

Should I convert the verb into a gerund? It seems that the verb differs from the gerund, and if B does the conversion, it doesn't quote A exactly. Something changes.

Best Answer

As "B" is quoting "A" directly, in written English you should place quote marks

What do you mean by "ask a question"?

In speech there are intonation and rhythmic indicators of this structure.

You shouldn't change it to "asking". If you say "What do you mean by asking a question?" it means "What is your purpose in asking a question". It doesn't ask about the words that A spoke, but asks why "A" asked a question. That doesn't make sense (because A didn't ask a question!)

Related Topic