Learn English – “On a Desert” or “In a Desert” and Common Usage

phrase-requestsphrase-usageprepositional-objects

I was reading to my daughter the other night and came across an awkward passage in Crockett Johnson's "Harold's Trip to the Sky":

"There was nothing to see. He was in the middle of a desert. No wonder he was so thirsty. But, luckily, he had brought his purple crayon. And he knew where to find water on a desert."

In my experience, common usage finds one "in a desert" rather than "on" one. Honestly, this is my first time encountering this particular usage anywhere.

Is it more common to say (verbally or in writing) that one is "in a desert" or "on a desert"? Has common usage of this phrase shifted since the book's original copyright date in 1957 or are there other reasons for this difference in usage? I have already seen other questions similar to this one such as "On a page" or "in a page" for a web page and I understand that prepositions are used interchangeably in some situations. My question is not about correct usage but common usage. Any examples from other written works would be appreciated.

Best Answer

Google NGRAMS shows "in the desert" to be much more common than "on the desert".

Some uses of "on the desert" have a preceding word, e.g., "bordering on the desert". But it's basically 200/1.

For "in a desert" vs. "on a desert," it's about 2/1.

"in a desert" is even more dominant when "on a desert island" is considered, since the phrase dominates the "on a desert" references.

Related Topic