Learn English – “Something as Received” versus “Receiving Something”

grammarmoodtenses

I am confused about distinguishing between the two sentences below.

  1. Receiving wisdom is better than learning the hard way.
  2. Received wisdom is better than learning the hard way.

The most-obvious reading of (1) I think is for "receiving" to be interpreted as a present continuous verb. There's a second reading where "receiving" is a gerund (in which it forms a compound subject with "wisdom.")

Both sentences are in the present tense but the gerund "receiving" in (1) superficially agrees with the tense, but the (some kind of adjectival verb) "received" in (2) appears to clash.

What type of grammatical principle explains "wisdom as received" or "received wisdom" (as in 2) an a part of speech other than a verb phrase? Is this an example of grammatical mood? If so, what mood is this?

Best Answer

I think you have already identified the difference in your question.

In phrase 1 the verb "learning" is referenced in both "receiving wisdom" and "learning the hard way".

In phrase 2 "received wisdom" is a noun phrase, whereas "learning the hard way" is a verb phrase. To create symmetry, you could write "Received wisdom is better than that learned the hard way." Where "that" refers to wisdom or a learned concept.