Starcraft – Are Automated Refineries/Extractors as fast as three workers

starcraft-2

In both the Wings of Liberty and Heart of the Swarm campaigns there are research options for automated refineries/extractors, which allow vespene gas to be harvested without a worker. This has obvious benefits, such as freeing more supply for combat units and allowing long-distance vespene gas harvesting, but I'm curious how fast the gas actually collects.

Assuming the command center/hatchery is as close as possible to the vespene geyser, will three workers harvest gas quicker than, slower than, or just as quickly as the automated building?

Best Answer

Automated extractors harvest at the same rate as extractors that have 3 drones.

I tested this on the Hand of Darkness mission. I choose this mission because it ends at 5:12 if you don't kill the first hybrid and you start with drones and one extractor.

I was able to harvest a total of 696 gas by 5:12 with and without the Automated Extractors ability. Turning on Vaspene Efficiency allowed me to gather a total of 845 gas with and without Automated Extractors by 5:12.

Results

+-------------------------+--------------------+-----------------------+
| Total Gas Harvested     | Vespene Efficiency | No Vespene Efficiency |
+-------------------------+--------------------+-----------------------+
| Automated Extractors    | 845                | 696                   |
| No Automated Extractors | 845                | 696                   |
+-------------------------+--------------------+-----------------------+

Note: The mission starts you off with 100 free gas, so the net gain is 100 gas less than the totals I posted above.