Intelligent Magic Item Communication Modes

dnd-3.5emagic-items

In the SRD, it is noted in the table under Intelligent Items ~ Languages Spoken By Item two footnotes 2 and 4.

Footnote 2 reads

'Like a character, an intelligent item speaks Common plus one language
per point of Intelligence bonus. It can communicate telepathically
with the wielder.'

And footnote 4 reads

The item can use either communication mode at will, with language use
as any speaking item. It can communicate telepathically with the
wielder.

Is there any particular reason why footnote 4 should repeat and emphasize the same information contained in footnote 2 'It can communicate telepathically with the wielder' when footnote 4 already acknowledges the item possesses both speech and telepathy and can use either communication mode at will?

Best Answer

The line serves no purpose

Any of the weapons in Footnote 4 already has telepathy, and telepathy is never tied to a specific language, so it does not matter if the wielder or anyone else also speaks the same language as the weapon. It can communicate telepathically with anyone. This makes the line entirely superfluous.

For what it's worth if with the languages the weapon would need to communicate telepathically with the wielder in the language it speaks, then the line would serve to ensure it can communicate, even if it does not speak the wielder's language. But that is not how telepathy works in 3.5.