[RPG] For the Catapult spell, is a 1/2-pound container holding 3 pounds of materials considered a valid target

dnd-5espellstargetingweight

The catapult spell description (EEPC, p. 15; XGtE, p. 150) states:

Choose one object weighing 1 to 5 pounds

A 0.5-pound container alone isn't eligible to be catapulted because it's too light.

If that container was holding 3 pounds of objects within it (putting the total at 3.5 pounds), would I be able to launch it with catapult?

Best Answer

Yes you can

The main question is if an container counts its content weight towards its own weight.

There is no explicit rule that says that a container is considered to count as it's weight plus its content but I would consider it logical. Especially that the exception to this have it specifically noted see Bag of holding.

Considering this I would say that the container with content can be used for this spell as long its not being worn or carried.

The second question is how the container and content are affected by the spell.

The Catapult spell has a very clear description of how the object moves:

The object flies in a straight line up to 90 feet in a direction you choose before falling to the ground. It stops early if it hits a solid surface.

This to me means that the object isn't just flung from it's point of origin using a ballistic trajectory. In other words the magic spell interacts with the object for the duration of its movement. This would mean the spell grabs the object and moves it along the line.

This I would say means the containers content stay in the container and impact on the target always counts as one impact.

The third question then is if i use this spell to hit a vampire with a bottle of holy water or something else with Alchemist's fire. Does is do extra damage?

My answer is no. Mostly because the spell doesn't say it does. Nor would you have it do extra damage if you used the spell to launch a sword.

As a DM I might allow you to change the damage type of the spell so the Alchemist fire would change the damage type to Fire, holy water might make it Radiant, a sword could make it Slashing and Catapulting an oil lamp would make it Fire damage. But this would be a house rule for my group.

The whole answer to question 3 is very much up for ruling by your own DM. There is no rule on how this works so your DM can rule it in any way he likes.