I'm involved in a home brew where my DM has allowed me to play as a combination of half-orc and half-elf. My character has the stats of a half-orc that simply has a slightly increased lifespan and some cosmetics of an elf, but that is entirely irrelevant to my question.
I write expanded backstories for a few characters that I've played for the sheer joy of writing but I'd like to keep things as lore-accurate as possible for these tales. I understand that an orc's genes are dominate in the child resulting in it simply being considered a Half-Orc for PC creation. However, this is just a story I'm writing outside of the game.
I've had people tell me to look back at the 1e monster manual (which I do not have) to see that orcs and elves cannot mate, but I wonder if this is just for the sake of preventing PCs being made as such.
In the general lore from any edition (i.e. setting neutral), can a male orc impregnate a female elf, or is there some genetic reason that an elf simply cannot birth the child of an orc?
Again, I don't need anyone to tell me that as a PC, this is not a thing. I just want to understand the lore of these races as such.
Best Answer
Traditionally no, but it may be possible, if rare.
According to AD&D-era lore, elves cannot breed with orcs at all. In Dragon magazine #60 (April 1982), the article "The Half-Elven Point of View" states:
The Complete Book of Elves (1992), p.20, says that it is rare for an elf to successfully reproduce with anything but a human:
The D&D 3e Races of Faerûn (2001), p.67, says that half-orcs carring some elvish blood might exist, but they may be a myth:
D&D 5e's Monster Manual (2014), p. 245, "Orc Crossbreeds", states definitively that orcs can reproduce with non-orc humanoids of similar size, though it doesn't say anything particularly for or against elves here:
There is such a thing as the "blessing of Luthic" described in the D&D 5e Volo's Guide to Monsters, but it extends an orc's lifespan, rather than allowing them to interbreed with elves in particular. In fact, according to the 3e Faiths & Pantheons p.150, Luthic hates the elven gods as traditional enemies of the orcs.