[RPG] Is the extra damage from Assassin’s Strike maximized on a critical

assassincritical-hitdnd-4e

The executioner assassin has the following power

Encounter

No Action

Trigger: You hit an enemy within 5 squares of you with an attack using a weapon.

Effect: The target takes 1d10 extra damage. If the target is helpless, this damage is maximized.

My question is the following.

Most striker extra damage features are maximized on a critical hit. Is this feature also maximized on a critical or only under the circumstances listed? Or is it maxed on a critical as well.

Best Answer

Yes, the extra damage is maximized on a crit.

From the Players Handbook FAQ:

  1. Which dice do I maximize when scoring a critical hit?

Only the dice you would normally roll to calculate damage are maximized. If another bonus (like from a weapon or feat) causes you to roll extra damage dice when scoring a critical hit, those dice are rolled as normal.

And from consensus on the WotC forums:

Which dice do you max on a critical hit? If a bonus (like from a weapon or feat) causes you to roll extra damage dice when scoring a critical hit, those dice are not maxed. Other dice like hunter's quarry, sneak attack, warlock's curse, etc. are all maxed. Discussed here and in the 4e PHB FAQ.

I see no reason that a power that triggers on a hit is any different from anything else like a class feature such as Sneak Attack or the free action granted by the Hunter's Quarry power.


As summarized by jprete:

The procedure here is something like the following: figure out what the damage roll would be without a critical hit, considering all effects; maximize that; and then go ahead and add bonus effects that only trigger on a crit, without maximizing them