[RPG] What can players do while waiting for a troll to regenerate

combatdnd-5eregeneration

Can players do anything while waiting for a troll to regenerate its hp on its next turn? For example: Player A drops troll’s hp to 0. Player B and Player C go before troll goes. Do I just skip their turn and say that the troll starts to stand back up or do I ask them what they do and let them know that combat isn't over, effectively spoiling that the troll will come back?

Best Answer

Players would remain in the turn order after a Troll is taken down to 0 hit points, it would be unfair to just skip their turns as they may take that time to heal themselves, use consumables, or generally buff up before whatever is coming next. If they haven't encountered Trolls before, they may just suspect you have some more creatures to come.

When utilising a Troll in combat, keep in mind the following things:

  • Trolls can only be killed by Fire or Acid, in the Regeneration trait it states "If the troll takes acid or fire damage, this trait doesn't function at the start of the troll's next turn.", and "The troll dies only if it starts its turn with 0 hit points and doesn't regenerate.", which combined means that the only way for the troll to start it's turn with 0 hit points and no Regeneration buff is to get it to 0 hit points with acid or fire, or thirdly, deal acid or fire damage while they're at 0 hit points but before their next turn.
  • Jeremy Crawford in the Dragon+ episode that aired 29th January 2019 that the instant death rule does not effect Trolls, Regeneration trumps that rule, so even reducing it to 0 hit points, with leftover damage equal to its max hit points, the Troll will still gain Regeneration buffs. However, while Regeneration trumps Instant Death, Disintegrate's chance of instant death trumps Regeneration, so you can still instant kill a Troll with that spell, as discussed in this post.

In conclusion, Trolls in D&D5e are much like their internet counterpart, hard to kill and relentlessly annoying unless you're prepared for them.