[RPG] Can a Shield be Disarmed

combat-maneuverdisarmingdnd-5eshield

The Player's Handbook describes the shield as being wielded in one hand.

However, the Armor category that displays the times to put on armor lists the shield is something that you don, and it takes one action to do so. Under this interpretation, can you even be disarmed of your shield, very much the way you cannot be disarmed of your armor?

Best Answer

Impossible to say

We have, effectively, three points of information. First,

  • the entry on the disarm variant rule states that

    A creature can use a weapon attack to knock a weapon or another item from a target's grasp.

    and the entry on the battlemaster’s disarming attack lets you

    When you hit a creature with a weapon attack, you can [...force...] it to drop one item of your choice that it's holding.

So the question becomes whether or not a shield is an item that you “hold” or is in your “grasp.” To answer that, we have two more points to consider:

  • The entry on shields says

    A shield [...] is carried in one hand.

  • While weapons don’t usually require an action to draw, as the Use an Object action states that

    You normally interact with an object while doing something else, such as when you draw a sword as part of an attack.

    shields instead require their own separate action to “don,” as indicated by the “donning and doffing armor” table on page 146.

These last two imply but do not state completely opposite answers to the question of whether or not a shield is a held item that can be disarmed. Neither one of them explicitly or conclusively says one way or the other, but “carried in one hand” suggests that the shield is merely held, while “donning” and taking extra time to do so implies that the shield is strapped on.

We do not have enough information to definitively state an answer one way or the other.

Related Topic